
OK, so I take back when I said that every closing Broadway show (or West End for that matter) should record the final night for release on DVD. As amazing as it is to share the event with people all over the world who could not be there, I fear that I would not have the emotional strength to watch each one!
Anyone who knows me will tell you that I am a complete RENThead. I saw the show for the first time in the summer of 2007 and it is due to that night that I am sat here now writing this blog. It blew me away and I havn't looked back since. I have been lucky enough to see the show 3 more times since then, as well as an interesting production of RENT Remixed (hmmmmmm) in London last year. I know the show inside out and have geeked it up to the vary highest level with this show; watching as much stuff as I could on youtube, reading articles 'till my head exploded, buying even vaguely related books, even mentioning the musical in three of my degree essays. So when I heard that they were going to film the final night of this epic show on Broadway (September 7th 2008), I was very excited.
I managed to get my hands on the DVD today, almost a year on. I reckon it was worth the wait! Film adaptations can be cool, but nothing compares to seeing a show live on stage - this DVD is the closest that you can get to that, with the added bonus that you can watch it again and again!
There were some great things about watching the show through cameras. You could never dream of getting that close to the action of a Broadway show (except perhaps Spring Awakening) in a normal situation. Close-up shots of individuals sometimes really heightened some scenes; allowing you to really engross yourself in what was going on. Not so cool was watching flying spit; though I suppose you have to give a little in that situation!
The cast were superb. As great as I think Anthony Rapp and Adam Pascall were as Mark and Roger, it was really refreshing to see someone else tackle these great roles. Adam Kantor was an amazing Mark (especially considering he's just out of college!) and Will Chase was a very convincing Roger.
The stand-out performance, in my opinion, was Eden Espinosa as Maureen. I was lucky enough to see her play this role on Broadway and she was even better than I remember! She was so fiesty, as is soooo important to play a good Maureen, but was also fantastic during the emotional scenes; you could really feel her heartache.
Tracie Thoms was great as Joanne, and it was fab to see that she has grown into the part since making the film, it really felt like her own. That was what I think made the cast so great. The original cast for RENT are iconic and it would be so easy to copy their performances. Infact I'm sure many audiences expect/hope for that. But the closing cast really made the show their own, whilst of course staying faithful to what the musical is all about.
Justin Johnson was amazing as Angel; it was so clear that he cared for the role greatly. He has an amazing and versatile voice, which came through especially in "Contact". How he could sing AND move like that in "Today 4u" is anyone's guess!
The only performance that I did not massively enjoy was Renee Goldsberry as Mimi. I saw her in the show and liked her, though she was not my favourite by any stretch. I felt in this recording, that her emotions seemed somewhat forced and unnatural. It was heightened by the vast emotions shown by the rest of the cast. By the final scene she was of course "in the zone" but I just felt it took her a little time to get there. That being said, he voice was sensational. Maybe it was just, having seen the extraordinary Tamyra Gray play the role in 2007, I had set my bar too high??
The music came across beautifully and the ability for the camera to search out action meant that I spotted things that I had never seen before (no mean feat!). Scenes such as "Christmas Bells" really benefitted from this. With more than 4 melodic lines woven over eachother, it was impossible to pick out the details of many of them. Until now. The sound balance was wonderful and the camera moved from person-to-person, allowing you to tune in to each individual line. Wonderful!
I hope that the cameras did not interfere too much with the energy and motion of the show. It did not appear to when watching it. They captured fantastically the raw energy of watching this show live and I am sure I will be watching it again in the next day or so!! I loved that they also took time at a few moments in the show to pan to the band - making the most of them being visible on stage.
Ok, so the show isn't perfect. There are holes in the story and not all of the lyrics are genius. But I think that's part of its charm. It is raw and edgy and thats what so many fans love about it. There is always that thought in the back of my mind: "I wonder what Jonathan Larson would have changed about the show had he lived longer. Would it have made it better?" But then that brings up the question of "had Jonathan Larson lived longer, would the story of RENT have sold so well?" I fell in love with the show before knowing the story of it's creation. But there is no doubt that the situation into which RENT was born created a lot of publicity for the show and put many bums on seats over the years.
The extra features on the DVD were great; I mean, what musical theatre fan doesn't want to sneak a peek backstage and hear the actors talk about what the show and it's characters mean to them. I think especially with a piece like RENT, that has so much attatched to it, even besides the story, it was important to document the closing of the show so explicitly. You couldn't help but be moved by the amount of people that the production touched. Even the man who ran the ticket lottery system shed a few tears on the last day!
It is crazy to think that the man who made all of this happen never got to see any of it. What a sad story in the history of theatre. Jonathan Laron's legacy is a great one, but it is such a shame that this great talent's life was cut short, just as he was starting to get some recognition for his work.
RENT became an overnight phenomenon and stayed that way for 12 years on Broadway, which is more than an achievement. The musical shows no sign of going away either, with the newly released School Edition of the show ready to be performed and the sell-out national tour in full swing. I highly recommend watching the DVD, whether you have seen the show before or not. Make sure you have a tissue ready though, as tears are inevitable!
No Day But Today!Flis xx